Bearing one another's
burdens since 1917.

We’re a leading provider of property & liability insurance for Christian ministries. Every policy we write, every decision we make, is out of a deep love for the Church.

Brotherhood Mutual by the Numbers

Years in Service

100+

Ministries Served

67,000+

Employees

600+

Employees and agents equally committed to ministry

Among our people you’ll find pastors, deacons, teachers, board members, mission trip leaders, worship leaders, and more. Our passion is to help ministries focus on advancing the gospel.

Request a quote

Making an impact

Brotherhood Mutual employees are involved in the community through service days, domestic mission trips through the CoMission program, and partnering with local ministries in Serbia through CoMission Serbia.
Additionally, churches across the country can apply for the Kingdom Advancing Grant℠. The grant is offered through the Brotherhood Mutual Foundation, a private nonprofit foundation dedicated to making contributions to encourage religious, charitable, and educational activities and operations. (Grant application opens January 2026.)

What our 67,000+ customers are saying

Dr. Scott Stancil

First Baptist Church

“Working with Brotherhood Mutual has truly been a blessing.

We have never lacked the necessary information to make a well-informed decision, allowing us to be good stewards of the Lord’s finances through His church. After more than 30 years in ministry, switching to Brotherhood Mutual has been one of the wisest and most beneficial partnerships I have enjoyed.”

Jonathan Mitchell

Northland Christian Church

“We had to make some tough decisions to cut our budget, while also working hard to keep ministry the priority.

Brotherhood Mutual is helping that become a reality, while maintaining the coverages that keep everything safe, secure, and covered.”

Dr. Michael W. Newman

Texas District LCMS

“We were seeking the best possible stewardship of our resources and found the price and service from Brotherhood Mutual to be outstanding.

We appreciate their clear communication and a sincere interest in our ministry. In addition to high quality coverage, we value the relationship and resources provided. It is truly a ministry partnership.”

Safety News

Monthly email newsletter

Get ministry-related risk management resources delivered to your inbox.