-
-
My Account
Our Structure
In 2024, Brotherhoood Mutual Insurance Company reached a pivotal milestone in its 107-year history of providing insurance and service for ministries. Final regulatory approval was granted by the Indiana Attorney General, Indiana Secretary of State, and the Indiana Insurance Commissioner, effective July 1, 2024, for the company structure to transition from a mutual insurance company to a stock insurance company that is indirectly, wholly owned by a mutual insurance holding company.
With this change, active policyholders of the insurance company acquired mutual membership and voting rights in Brotherhood Mutual Holding Company, effective July 1, 2024. Members are entitled to vote either in person or by proxy on key decisions, such as the appointment of the Directors at the mutual insurance holding company's annual member’s meeting. Members are able to cast only one vote regardless of the number of policies they purchase.
Brotherhood Mutual Holding Company | Board of Directors
The current Directors of the mutual insurance holding company are listed below.
Mark A. Robison
CPA, CPCU
Chairman of the Board & President
Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company
Matthew G. Hirschy
CPA, CPCU
Senior Vice President & Treasurer
Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company
Michael J. Allison
JD, CPCU
Vice President, Chief Counsel & Secretary
Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company
Suzanne Allison-Davis
JD, MBA
President
Greenville University
Lashanna “Sha” Farley
Chief Human Resources Officer
Kenosis Leadership LLC
Chris L. Goeglein
MBA
Managing Principal
True North Strategic Advisors, LLC
Sammy T. Mah
Private Consultant
Former President & CEO
World Relief
Kathy B. Rogers
CSP
President & CEO
KB Search Team, LLC
Luke M. Roush
Co-Founder & Co-CEO
Sovereign's Capital Management
Bryan C. Taylor
Chief Executive Officer
Cornerstone Management
Robert Wallstrom
Principal & Founder
LTV Advisory
Michael Wong
CPA, CGMA
Chief Financial & Operations Officer
Open Doors USAThe directors of Brotherhood Mutual Holding Company also serve as the directors of Brotherhood Holding Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Brotherhood Mutual Holding Company.
Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company - A Stock Insurance Company | Board of Directors
The following Directors of the Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company are approved for appointment by the Directors of the Brotherhood Mutual Holding Company.
Mark A. Robison
CPA, CPCU
Chairman & President
Matthew G. Hirschy
CPA, CPCU
Senior Vice President & Treasurer
Michael J. Allison
JD, CPCU
Vice President
Chief Counsel & Secretary
Dan Book
CIC, AIC
Vice President
Sales
Steve Case
JD, CPCU
Vice President
General Counsel - Affiliates
Scott A. Figgins
MBA, CPCU
Senior Vice President
Insurance Operations
Dustin Grogg
CPCU, ARM, ARe
Vice President
Underwriting
Jennifer Hansen
CPA, MBA, CPCU
Vice President
Finance
Dave Lantz
CPCU, AIC
Vice President
Claims
Daryl Pannabecker
CPCU
Vice President
Information Technology
Sabra Rowley
CPA, CPCU
Vice President
Finance & Data Analytics - Affiliates
Josh Spencer
ACAS, ASA, MAAA, CERA, CPCU
Chief Actuary, Vice President
Research & Development
Mitzi Thomas
ABC
Vice President
Marketing
Abel Travis
MBA
Senior Vice President
Affiliate Operations
Kathleen J. Turpin
JD, CPCU, AIM
Vice President
Human Resources
Matthew Zurbuch
Vice President
Chief Investment OfficerTo learn more about the senior executive and executive leadership teams at Brotherhood Mutual visit our Leadership Team page.