What Customers Say

Geyer Springs First Baptist Church
Joe Statton
Executive Pastor

“We’ve been a Brotherhood Mutual customer for more than 30 years. They have a great product with competitive pricing, and they’re responsive to our claims. I’ve always had a good experience with Brotherhood Mutual.”

Conway Christian School
Birdie Lentz
Human Resources

“Brotherhood Mutual is usually one step ahead in their coverages compared to others. The insurance package Brotherhood Mutual designed for our school fit our specific needs while costing us less money than other carriers.”

Plymouth Christian Academy
Brad Hovermale
Business Manager

“Our church and school have unique needs. It's paramount to us that our insurance provider understands the ins and outs of ministry and can tailor solutions to meet our specific ministry activities. Brotherhood Mutual fits that requirement for us.”

Flatirons Community Church
Michael Koehn
Chief Financial Officer

“Flatirons is rapidly expanding with new campuses and a school, and Brotherhood Mutual has been there every step of the way, helping us to make sure we can offer the types of ministries that God is calling us to provide. When I have a question, I get a response in a very timely manner and the folks at Brotherhood Mutual are not only knowledgeable, but also kind. In this day and age, that’s a rare combination.”

Virginia Baptist College
Sherry Davis
Chief Financial Officer

“I was looking for a payroll solution that helps with multi-state compliance as we have instructors located all over the country. I was nervous about starting with a payroll service, but the knowledgeable staff members at MinistryWorks^® hold your hand through the onboarding process and welcome any questions you have. MinistryWorks payroll speaks for itself, but the customer service is the cherry on top!”

River Valley Ranch
Jon Bisset
Executive Director

“Other carriers might offer coverage for less money, but it’s not the same service as we get from Brotherhood Mutual. Quality and price are both important. We get a good value for our needs.”

Green Ridge Assembly of God
Dave Twiss
Lead Pastor

“Brotherhood Mutual was very accommodating and helped us keep things as safe as possible with the home makeover project. The company has always been very good about that.”

Timberline Church
Karen Bauer
Facility and Events Manager

“We look to Brotherhood Mutual frequently for solutions to out-of-the-box issues. We always get sound advice on how to proceed. Brotherhood Mutual is responsive, kind, and helpful. I always get a quick answer to what I think are difficult situations. Never once have I called and felt like I was bothering someone. They are so easy to work with and very knowledgeable.”

Missionary Church USA
Don Williams
Director of Operations

“I deeply appreciate the ministry you provide through Legal Assist. I recommend you almost every week to the family of churches throughout the Missionary Church USA.”

Visalia First
Mark DiGirolamo
Executive Pastor – Chief of Operations

“We used another company for our church coverage for many years. Upon a review of not only the costs but services offered, we discovered Brotherhood Mutual far exceeded our expectations. Our Rep has been more than willing to sit with us to hear concerns and then work through them. Brotherhood Mutual understands churches and the unique needs and has served us well. I have recommended Brotherhood Mutual to other churches and would encourage you to explore what they might be able to do for you.”